In this post…
In the grand experiment of democracy, one fatal flaw lurks beneath the surface: the intelligence level of the average citizen. While democracy promises equality, fairness, and a government that represents the will of the people, it’s only as effective as the people themselves. What happens when the majority of voters aren’t well-informed, thoughtful, or rational in their decision-making? Can democracy survive in a society where the collective intelligence is mediocre at best and dangerously uninformed at worst?
The Fatal Flaw in Democracy: Majority Rule and the Average Citizen’s Intelligence
At the heart of democracy is majority rule—the idea that the most popular choice of the people should prevail. However, as the late comedian George Carlin pointed out, this idea rests on a shaky foundation. Carlin said, “Think about how stupid the average person is, then realize that half of them are stupider than that!” It’s a sobering observation that speaks to the heart of a deep and uncomfortable truth: the collective wisdom of the populace may not always be up to the task of electing competent leaders.
In theory, a democracy should elevate the best and brightest to positions of power. But in reality, the voting process often reflects the lowest common denominator of public understanding. People tend to vote for candidates who resemble them, not necessarily for those with the greatest intelligence or most capable leadership skills. As a result, we often find ourselves with mediocre politicians at best, and at worst, leaders who are outright incompetent.
This phenomenon is especially troubling in an age where information is more accessible than ever. Yet, despite the availability of facts, we see widespread misinformation, polarization, and an overall lack of critical thinking. Democracy, which requires an informed electorate to function properly, is at risk of being undermined by a public that often prefers emotional appeals over rational discourse.
Education: The Only Way to Save Democracy
The key to improving democracy lies in education. If we are to save democracy from falling victim to the shortcomings of its citizens, we need to focus on educating the public—not just in basic literacy, but in critical thinking, empathy, and awareness of the complexities of governance.
Education should aim to promote an understanding of the world beyond one’s personal bubble. People need to be able to evaluate policies and candidates with a critical eye, considering not just their personal beliefs but the broader impact of decisions on society as a whole. This means teaching citizens how to think, not just what to think. It means getting them out of their echo chambers and into the real world. Only through education can we cultivate a population capable of making informed decisions that strengthen the democratic process rather than undermine it.
Education must go beyond the classroom. It should be a lifelong pursuit, accessible to all, regardless of age, background, or socioeconomic status. In a society where citizens are empowered with knowledge, they can collectively build a more informed electorate and demand better leadership.
How Druidry and Paganism Can Help Educate the Public
It might seem unconventional to suggest that Druidry and Paganism could play a role in improving democracy. However, these ancient spiritual traditions can offer valuable insights into the development of a more thoughtful, compassionate, and enlightened citizenry. Druidry and Paganism can encourage individuals to think critically, live harmoniously with the natural world, and engage deeply with the mysteries of life.
Druidry, for example, places a high value on wisdom, knowledge, and self-reflection. It encourages us to seek out the truth through nature, study, and spiritual practices. By embracing the Druidic emphasis on learning and self-awareness, we can inspire people to approach life with a greater sense of curiosity and humility, qualities that are essential for a thriving democracy.
Paganism, with its emphasis on inclusivity, diversity, and interconnectedness, can help to develop empathy and understanding. In a political landscape that often feels fragmented and divided, Paganism’s message of unity through diversity is more important than ever. By promoting a worldview that recognizes the inherent value of every individual, Paganism can contribute to a more compassionate and respectful discourse in society.
Democracy’s Future: Will We Have One After the Next Four Years?
The state of democracy today is precarious. With growing polarization, misinformation, and a general decline in civic engagement, it’s unclear whether our democratic systems can withstand the challenges they face. We’ve chosen not one but multiple leaders who openly embrace fascism through things like Project 2025. As Carlin suggested, we may not be as smart as we think, and when democracy is dependent on the collective intelligence of its people, this could spell disaster.
However, it’s not too late to course-correct. By prioritizing education and embracing philosophical and spiritual practices like those found in Druidry and Paganism, we can create a more thoughtful and informed electorate. If we rise to the challenge, democracy might just have a fighting chance.
But the clock is ticking. With the next four years shaping up to be a critical period in political history, the question remains: Will we rise to the occasion, or will we fall victim to the flaws of our own collective intelligence? The future of democracy may depend on it.
Share Your Thoughts: Are We Too Dumb for Democracy?
What do you think? Is education a way to save democracy in America and in the world? Share your thoughts in the comments below!